It must also be securely installed and appropriate for the building's structural requirements.
The accident demonstrated that a small design decision can have enormous consequences when it involves an elevated opening.
Why warning signs are not enough
A sign saying that a window should remain closed is useful, but it cannot guarantee safety.
Warning signs are only one component of a comprehensive safety system.
A facility should also consider:
-
Locks or restricted-opening mechanisms.
-
Protective railings where required.
-
Appropriate safety glazing.
-
Sufficient clearance behind exercise machines.
-
Regular inspections of windows and equipment.
-
Clear maintenance procedures.
-
Staff responsibility for securing hazardous areas.
If a window must be opened for cleaning, nearby equipment should be taken out of use until the opening is secured.
These precautions are not complicated concepts.
They are basic elements of responsible facility management.
The responsibility of a gym owner
A gym owner does more than purchase exercise machines and collect membership fees.
The business also has a responsibility to maintain an environment in which customers can use those machines without being exposed to unreasonable and preventable dangers.
This includes inspecting the premises, identifying hazards and ensuring that employees understand their responsibilities.
Customers should not have to become building-safety experts before stepping onto a treadmill.
They should be able to expect that obvious hazards have already been addressed.
The Pontianak case eventually became a legal matter, but its significance extended beyond one business or one city.
It raised a broader question for fitness facilities everywhere: are their safety procedures designed around what can actually happen, or only around what managers hope will never happen?
Chapter 4: The Court Case, Legal Responsibility and a Family's Difficult Decision
The investigation into the accident continued after the initial shock had passed.
For Fathiya's family, the loss could not be reversed. However, the legal proceedings offered an opportunity to examine the circumstances surrounding her death and determine whether responsibility should be assigned.
The case also became an important discussion about the relationship between negligence, public safety and the responsibilities of business owners.
The gym owner became a suspect
In July 2024, Indonesian police announced that the owner of K-GYM had been named a suspect.
The decision followed an investigation that included witness interviews and the collection of evidence.
According to reports from detikcom and CNN Indonesia, investigators examined the placement of the treadmill, the condition of the window and the absence of adequate protective measures.
The owner was investigated under Article 359 of Indonesia's Criminal Code, which concerns negligence resulting in another person's death.
This was a significant development because the case was no longer being treated simply as an unfortunate sporting accident.
Investigators were examining whether the facility had failed to provide reasonable protection against an identifiable danger.
What did the prosecution need to establish?
In cases involving alleged negligence, investigators and courts must examine the relationship between a person's responsibilities and the harm that occurred.
A business owner does not automatically become criminally responsible every time a customer experiences an accident.
The relevant questions include whether a duty of care existed, whether reasonable precautions were neglected and whether that failure contributed to the fatal outcome.
In the Pontianak case, the proximity of the treadmill to the open window became particularly important.
The absence of a protective railing and the reported condition of the window also formed part of the legal discussion.
The prosecution sought to establish that the danger was foreseeable and that appropriate measures should have been taken.
The defense, meanwhile, disputed aspects of the criminal allegations and emphasized the circumstances surrounding the accident.
A case that continued into the courtroom
The proceedings eventually reached the Pontianak District Court.
A report published by the Indonesian Supreme Court's news service in September 2025 described the court's decision and the role of restorative justice.
The gym owner, Suyadi, also known as Ahian, was found guilty of negligence resulting in death.
The court imposed a conditional sentence rather than an immediate custodial sentence.
Reporting on the judgment described a sentence of one year of imprisonment with a six-month probationary period.
The decision reflected the court's consideration of the agreement reached between the defendant and the victim's family.
The family accepted an agreement
One of the most emotional aspects of the proceedings involved the family's decision to accept an apology and an agreement concerning responsibility and improvements to the facility.
For families who lose someone unexpectedly, legal proceedings can be extremely difficult.
They must confront the circumstances of the death while also deciding what kind of outcome they hope to achieve.
Some families seek the strongest possible punishment.
Others place greater importance on acknowledgment, accountability and preventing similar incidents.
In this case, the court considered the agreement reached between the parties.
The family reportedly accepted the defendant's apology and hoped that the safety improvements would help prevent another tragedy.
This did not mean that the woman's death was unimportant or that the underlying safety concerns disappeared.
Rather, the court considered whether a restorative approach could contribute to accountability and practical changes.
The court required safety improvements
A particularly important part of the outcome involved the future condition of the gym.
According to the court-related reporting, the owner was required to improve the facility's safety arrangements.
These improvements included installing protective railings on windows and reorganizing exercise equipment to meet safety requirements.
This is significant because a legal outcome should ideally produce more than a decision about punishment.
When an accident exposes a dangerous design, the underlying hazard must be addressed.
A judgment that encourages physical improvements can help protect future customers.
However, the effectiveness of such measures depends on whether they are actually implemented and maintained.
Why restorative justice attracted attention
Restorative justice focuses on addressing harm through accountability, acknowledgment and efforts to repair the consequences of wrongdoing.
It does not necessarily eliminate criminal responsibility.
Instead, it can provide a framework in which the affected family and the person responsible reach an agreement under appropriate legal supervision.
The Pontianak case attracted attention because the court considered the family's agreement while also requiring meaningful changes to the facility.
The approach raised questions about how justice should balance punishment, reconciliation and public protection.
For the family, forgiveness may have been a personal decision that helped them move forward.
For the wider community, the more important question remained whether the gym would become safer.
A promise to improve a facility is meaningful only when it leads to lasting changes.
A lesson that extends beyond one courtroom
The case illustrates that safety responsibilities do not end when a customer signs a membership agreement.
A person entering a gym expects to use equipment in an environment that has been reasonably designed and maintained.
Owners must take foreseeable dangers seriously, particularly when exercise equipment is positioned near elevated windows or other dangerous openings.
The court proceedings also demonstrated that a fatal accident can have consequences long after the initial emergency.