That is not inconsistency. It is an understanding that effective leadership requires flexibility.
Chapter 9: The Qualities You Should Look for in a Real Vice President
The picture is a fun way to think about leadership, but choosing a real executive requires a much more careful process.
A candidate's appearance should never be treated as evidence of competence. A serious appointment should be based on qualifications, relevant experience, professional conduct, judgment, and the ability to work effectively with others.
Here are several qualities that matter regardless of which candidate style you preferred.
Integrity
A vice president may have access to sensitive information, financial decisions, employee matters, and strategic plans.
The person must be trustworthy.
Integrity involves being honest, acknowledging mistakes, respecting confidentiality, and avoiding conflicts of interest.
A highly intelligent executive who cannot be trusted may create greater risks than someone with less experience but strong ethical judgment.
Sound judgment
Executives often make decisions with incomplete information.
A good vice president needs to recognize what is known, what remains uncertain, and which risks deserve attention.
They should be able to explain why they support a particular course of action and identify circumstances that might require a different decision.
Communication
A vice president communicates with the president, employees, customers, partners, and sometimes the public.
They must be able to explain complex matters clearly, listen carefully, and adapt their communication style to different audiences.
Good communication is not simply speaking confidently. It also involves asking questions and checking whether people have understood important information.
Accountability
A strong executive accepts responsibility for results.
They do not automatically blame colleagues when a project fails. They investigate what happened, identify what can be improved, and help the team move forward.
Accountability also means recognizing when a decision has produced an unintended result.
Emotional intelligence
Executives work with people who have different personalities, backgrounds, responsibilities, and pressures.
Emotional intelligence can help them recognize emotional reactions, manage difficult conversations, and respond thoughtfully.
This does not mean suppressing disagreement. It means understanding how to address it productively.
Strategic thinking
A vice president must understand more than the immediate task.
They should be able to consider how today's decision may affect the company months or years later.
This requires an understanding of customers, competitors, finances, operations, and the wider environment in which the company operates.
Adaptability
Plans change.
A good vice president can adjust when new information appears, when circumstances shift, or when an original strategy is no longer effective.
Adaptability does not mean changing direction every time someone suggests something new. It means knowing when the evidence justifies a change.
The ability to develop other people
A vice president should not become the only person capable of solving problems.
Strong leaders help other employees develop skills, take responsibility, and make good decisions.
When a team depends entirely on one executive, the organization becomes vulnerable.
A capable vice president builds a stronger organization rather than simply becoming indispensable.
Chapter 10: A Simple Reflection Exercise After You Choose
Now that you have read the four interpretations, consider returning to the image and thinking about your choice again.
The aim is not to change your answer to something that sounds more impressive. It is to understand the reason behind your preference.
Ask yourself these questions:
1. What attracted you first?
Was it the candidate's professional appearance, distinctive style, calm presentation, or practical look?
Your answer may reveal which qualities you notice first when meeting someone.
2. What quality would make you trust this person?
Would you trust them because they are organized, imaginative, empathetic, or decisive?
Try to identify the behaviour behind the impression.
3. What would you expect this person to do during a crisis?
Would you want them to create a plan, develop an alternative, bring people together, or take immediate action?
Your answer may show what you believe leadership should look like under pressure.
4. What weakness would you be willing to manage?
Every leadership strength can become a weakness when taken too far.
Structure can become rigidity. Creativity can become a lack of focus. Diplomacy can become avoidance. Decisiveness can become impulsiveness.
The best leaders understand their own limitations and build teams that compensate for them.
5. Would you hire someone who thinks differently from you?
This may be the most important question.
A vice president should not simply agree with the president. They should be able to challenge decisions respectfully, present alternative views, and identify risks that the president may have overlooked.
A team made up entirely of people who think alike can become comfortable but vulnerable to blind spots.
What if you cannot choose just one?
Some readers may find themselves torn between two candidates.
Perhaps you like Number 1's reliability but also appreciate Number 2's imagination. Maybe you admire Number 3's empathy while wanting Number 4's decisiveness.
That is perfectly reasonable.
The four descriptions represent different qualities, not four fixed types of human beings. A real person can be organized and creative, empathetic and decisive, or independent and highly collaborative.
In fact, the strongest executives often demonstrate several of these qualities depending on the situation.
The exercise is most useful when it helps you recognize what you value, not when it forces you into a narrow category.
Chapter 11: The Final Answer — Your Choice Is a Window Into Your Priorities
So, who would you hire as your vice president?
If you chose Number 1, you may place reliability, discipline, and professional standards at the top of your list. You want someone who can create order, protect important responsibilities, and make sure promises become results.
If you chose Number 2, you may value imagination, independence, and fresh thinking. You want someone who can question old assumptions, identify opportunities, and help the company adapt.
If you chose Number 3, you may believe that strong relationships are essential to lasting success. You want someone who listens, builds trust, handles disagreements thoughtfully, and understands the people behind the business.
If you chose Number 4, you may admire confidence, initiative, and practical action. You want someone who can take responsibility, solve problems, and move forward without waiting for constant instructions.
But there is one final point worth remembering.
The best vice president is not necessarily the person who looks the most professional, creative, elegant, or confident. It is the person whose actual abilities, values, and experience match the needs of the organization.
A successful president needs more than someone who agrees with every decision. They need a trusted partner who can contribute different strengths, identify weaknesses, and help the organization make better choices.
Perhaps the most interesting result of this exercise is not the number you selected. It is the reason you selected it.
Did you choose the person who would make your life easier? The person who would challenge you? The person who could bring people together? Or the person who would take action when everyone else was still discussing the problem?
Your answer may offer a small glimpse into the qualities you admire most in others—and perhaps the qualities you are trying to develop in yourself.
There is no wrong choice. The strongest leadership teams need structure, creativity, empathy, and decisive action.
So, which number did you choose: 1, 2, 3, or 4? And what made that candidate stand out to you?