We sat in my car for nearly an hour after leaving the clinic.
Emily stared through the windshield.
Then she laughed.
It was a strange, broken sound.
"Same nose," she whispered.
I looked at her.
"Same stubborn chin."
Neither of us smiled.
"Sarah, what if it's true?"
I thought about the hedge between our childhood homes. The goldfish funeral. The birthday parties. The way our mothers used to look at each other whenever someone mentioned how similar we appeared.
"What if we've been sisters for twenty-five years and didn't know it?" I said.
That evening, we went to see our mothers.
My mother, Marie, still lived in the yellow house on Sycamore Lane. She was sixty-five. My father, Erik, had died six years earlier.
Barbara, Emily's mother, still lived in the blue house next door with her husband, Mike.
We arrived at my mother's house at seven.
She opened the door wearing an apron. She had been baking, and the smell of something sweet filled the hallway.
But when she saw our faces, her smile disappeared.
"Mom," I said. "Can you call Barbara? We need to talk to both of you."
She looked at me.
Then at Emily.
For a moment, she seemed to be searching our faces for something.
Finally, she removed her apron.
"I'll call her," she said quietly.
Barbara arrived through the same opening in the hedge that Emily and I had used as children.
She entered the kitchen and sat beside my mother.
Two women who had been neighbors for more than thirty years.
Two women who suddenly seemed to know exactly why we had come.
I placed the genetic reports on the table.
"Dr. Harrison asked us whether Emily and I are biologically related."
My voice shook.
My mother covered her mouth.
Barbara closed her eyes.
Neither woman laughed.
Neither called the question ridiculous.
They simply looked at each other.
And that was when I knew there was something they had never told us.
Barbara spoke first.
"Mike couldn't have children," she said.
Emily stared at her.
"When he was nineteen, he had the mumps. It caused serious damage, and we eventually learned that he was infertile."
Barbara looked down at her hands.
"He was devastated. He was so ashamed that he made me promise never to tell anyone. Not his family. Not you."
Then my mother began speaking.
"Your father had a very low sperm count," she said to me. "The doctors told us that conceiving naturally would be extremely unlikely."
She swallowed.
"Erik was devastated too. He made me promise to keep it private."
The two women had something else in common.
They had both visited a fertility clinic in Columbus in the early 1990s.
The clinic had been run by a doctor named Gerald Whitcomb.
"He told us he used donor sperm from medical students," Barbara explained. "Young, healthy men from Ohio State. He said everything had been screened."
My mother nodded.
"He told us the donors were selected to resemble our husbands. Similar coloring, similar build. He said that would make it easier for the children to feel connected to their families."
Barbara had gone to the clinic in March 1993.
Emily was born in December.
My mother had gone in April 1992.
I was born in January 1993.
We looked at each other.
"Did you know?" I asked.
My mother began crying.
"Not at first."
Barbara explained that the two families had only started to suspect something after noticing how similar Emily and I looked as children.
There was one detail they could never forget.
Both girls had a small brown birthmark behind the left knee.
A little shape resembling a bean.
Emily and I had even given them a nickname.
Our twin beans.
Barbara remembered approaching my mother one evening after the children had gone to bed. They sat at the kitchen table until two in the morning, discussing the possibility that the same donor might have been used for both pregnancies.
They had no DNA testing to confirm it.
But they suspected the truth.
"Why didn't you tell us?" Emily asked.
Her voice was breaking.
My mother looked at Barbara.
"Because of your fathers," she said.
"They were ashamed," Barbara added. "Neither knew what had happened to the other family. We were afraid of hurting them."
"And because of you two," my mother whispered.
She looked at us.
"You loved each other so much. We thought telling you would change everything."
I stared at the two women.
They had allowed us to grow up believing we were simply best friends.
But they had known, for decades, that we might be something more.
Then I remembered the other finding in Dr. Harrison's report.
The donor.
I took out my phone.
"There's something else," I said. "The test suggests we may also be related to him."
My mother went pale.
"What was the donor's name?"
"Daniel."
Barbara slowly turned toward her.
"Marie," she whispered. "Do you remember who founded Heritage Cryobank?"
My mother shook her head.
I searched for the information.
And when the name appeared on my screen, nobody in that kitchen moved.
It was Gerald Whitcomb.
The same doctor who had treated our mothers.