Chief Miller’s dark eyes shifted slowly toward me. "The bus did not crash anywhere along its regular route, Ms. Emmy."
"That doesn't prove someone hijacked it," I pressed, stepping down from the bleachers. "Arthur could have swerved to avoid an animal or pulled onto a farm lane if the brakes failed. Are your officers searching the valley floor?"
His jaw tightened almost imperceptibly. "The mountain routes are our primary focus right now."
"Why? Arthur’s route runs straight through the valley! The mountains are miles in the opposite direction!"
"Because the northern logging trails offer heavy tree cover and direct access out of the county," he replied smoothly,though his gaze refused to meet mine for more than a second.
"What about the local farms along the creek?" I demanded. "There are dozens of old barns and outbuildings down there!"
"We have patrol units checking local properties," he said, his tone growing clipped and impatient. "Ms. Emmy, I need you to sit down."
"My nine-year-old daughters are missing!"
"So are eleven other children," Chief Miller snapped, before quickly catching himself and lowering his voice. "We need everyone to remain calm so my officers can do their jobs."
My hands shook with fury as another father gently pulled me back down onto the bench. Watching Chief Miller turn back to the map, a cold, prickling suspicion began to crawl up my spine. Over and over, his marker circled the northern mountain roads, the abandoned quarry, and the state forest—yet not once did his hand move toward the valley floor.
At 11:20 a.m., I dialed Jeniffer’s cell phone for the eighteenth time. Mary didn't have a phone yet; I had promised she could get one on her tenth birthday, since Jeniffer had only received hers early for safety after joining the after-school running club. That small, innocent rule now felt like a knife twisting in my chest. Every time the call went straight to voicemail, I pictured Mary begging to borrow her sister's phone, and nobody answering on the other end.
At noon, Chief Miller stepped outside to deliver a brief statement to the local news crews gathering behind the yellow tape. Standing near the propped-open gym doors, I heard a reporter shout, "Chief, is there a ransom demand?"
"Not at this time," Miller replied grimly.
"Do you have a suspect in mind?"
"We are actively investigating the bus driver's background."
I pushed past a deputy and stepped out onto the concrete walkway. "Arthur would never hurt those kids!"
Chief Miller turned to look at me as if I were a minor inconvenience he had already solved. "You don't know that, ma'am."
"I know he has driven my daughters every single weekday for six years without fail!"
"People hide things, Ms. Emmy," he said softly, leaning in just enough that the microphones wouldn't catch his words."Sometimes for decades."
Something in the cold, deliberate way he delivered that sentence made the hairs on my arms stand up. "Do you know Arthur personally?" I asked.
A muscle flickered in his jaw. "I know his criminal record."
"What record?"
Before he could utter another word, two deputies stepped smoothly between us, blocking my view. "Ms. Emmy, please return inside the gym immediately." Chief Miller turned on his heel and walked briskly toward his cruiser without looking back—leaving me staring after him, completely unaware that within two hours, a faint signal from underground would expose why the chief was so desperate to keep everyone away from the valley.
Chapter 3: The Whisper from Underground
By two o'clock in the afternoon, the air inside the gymnasium felt thick and suffocating, heavy with the smell of cold coffee and quiet despair. I sat hunched forward with my elbows on my knees, staring relentlessly at the dark screen of my cell phone, praying for it to light up.
At 2:14 p.m., it violently buzzed against my palm.
The screen flashed Restricted Number. For half a second, my heart sank, assuming it was another local reporter fishing for a quote. Then, a faint, flickering GPS ping notification popped up right beneath the caller ID. It was Jeniffer’s phone.
My thumb slipped twice before I managed to swipe answer, pressing the speaker tightly against my ear. "Jeniffer?! Baby, can you hear me?!"
At first, nobody spoke. All I could hear was a wall of heavy static, a low, rhythmic metallic hum, and the unmistakable sound of someone breathing rapidly right next to the microphone.
"Jeniffer, please! Talk to Mommy!"
Before another second passed, the line abruptly disconnected. Before I could even sob in frustration, a new voicemail notification chimed on my screen—the weak underground signal had forced the call to drop, sending through a prerecorded audio message instead. My hands trembled so violently I nearly dropped the phone onto the gym floor as I hit play and pressed the speaker button.