And Sadie would see it too.
CHAPTER 2: THE PICTURE THAT CHANGED EVERYTHING
At 9:40 that night, Tasha posted a picture.
Jodi was lying in bed, scrolling through Facebook without really paying attention. She wasn't looking for anything in particular. It was simply what she did when sleep refused to come.
She and Tasha weren't close, but they were Facebook friends.
In a small South Dakota community, that was hardly unusual. People accepted requests from former classmates, neighbors, relatives, and people they had once met at a school event. Sometimes they barely spoke in real life.
Tasha's post appeared near the top of Jodi's feed.
The photograph showed Madison, her seventeen-year-old daughter, standing in front of a three-way mirror inside a dress boutique in Sioux Falls.
She was wearing a champagne-gold gown.
It was long and fitted, covered in sequins that caught the light. A slit ran up one side, and delicate straps rested on her shoulders. Her blonde hair fell loosely down her back as she smiled over her shoulder at the camera.
She looked excited.
She looked confident.
She looked like a girl who had just found the dress she had been dreaming about.
Jodi recognized the store immediately.
Boutique 605.
It was a well-known dress shop on Phillips Avenue in downtown Sioux Falls. Prom season brought girls from surrounding towns, and the boutique carried gowns that were often far more expensive than anything an ordinary family could casually purchase.
Jodi knew the prices.
They started around four hundred dollars.
Some were considerably more expensive.
Tasha's caption read:
Found THE dress! Madison's going to be the prettiest girl at Mitchell prom. Thank you Boutique 605!
Jodi stared at the photograph.
Then she noticed the comments.
Rory had already responded.
His comment was near the top, posted just eight minutes after Tasha shared the picture.
Beautiful girl. So proud. ❤️
Jodi read it once.
Then again.
Then a third time.
Four hours earlier, Rory had told Sadie he couldn't afford a prom dress because welding work had been slow. He was getting only three days a week at the shop, he had said.
Yet here was his family celebrating Madison's six-hundred-dollar gown.
Jodi didn't know whether Rory had paid for the dress, whether Tasha had purchased it herself, or whether someone else had helped.
She knew only what she could see.
Madison had a beautiful new dress.
Rory was publicly celebrating her.
And Sadie had been told there wasn't enough money.
Jodi opened Rory's profile and began scrolling.
She went back through his posts, looking for the last time he had written something about Sadie.
September.
Her homecoming picture.
Nothing more than a small heart.
November, when Sadie had received a volleyball trophy.
Another heart.
January, on her seventeenth birthday, when Jodi had posted a photograph of her daughter smiling beside a birthday cake.
No comment.
No words.
Just a reaction.
Jodi tried to remember the last time Rory had written something like Beautiful girl. So proud beneath one of Sadie's photographs.
She couldn't.
Across the hallway, a door opened.
Jodi lifted her head.
Sadie's bedroom door.
She heard her daughter walk into the bathroom. A moment later, the water began running.
Then the bathroom door opened, and Sadie's bedroom door closed again.
Very softly.
Jodi knew.
Sadie had seen the photograph.
Of course she had.
She was seventeen. She followed her father, Tasha, and Madison. She knew what everyone was doing, where they were going, and what was happening in the lives of the people she loved.
She had probably seen the post before her mother did.
She had seen the dress.
She had seen the price, or at least understood that it was expensive.
And she had seen her father's comment.
Jodi got out of bed.
She walked into the hallway and stopped outside Sadie's room. The house was dark except for the faint line of light beneath the door.
Her hand moved toward the doorknob.
She wanted to open it.
She wanted to sit beside her daughter and say that she deserved better. That she wasn't asking for too much. That a father should not make his child feel as though her dreams were an unreasonable expense.
But she didn't open the door.
Instead, she stood there listening.
There was no crying.
Only slow, careful breathing.
The kind of breathing people do when they are trying very hard not to make a sound.
Jodi returned to her room.
She lay down, placed her phone on the bedside table, and stared into the darkness.
She thought about the phone call.
She thought about the photograph.
She thought about Sadie's two quiet sentences.
That's fine, Dad.
It's totally fine.
And she began to understand something that made her feel even worse than anger.
Sadie wasn't just disappointed about a dress.
She was learning how to make her disappointment invisible.
Jodi stayed awake until two in the morning.
She had Rory's number open on her phone. Her thumb hovered over the call button.
She could have woken him up.
She could have demanded an explanation.
But before making that call, she had to remember the eleven years that came before it.
And those eleven years had taught her exactly how the conversation would end.
CHAPTER 3: ELEVEN YEARS OF PROMISES
Jodi did not call Rory that night.
She wanted to.