At two in the morning, with the house silent and her daughter asleep behind a closed bedroom door, she had his number pulled up on her phone.
Her thumb was close to the screen.
One tap, and he would hear her voice.
She could tell him what she thought of the photograph. She could ask why he had enough money to celebrate Madison's dress but not enough to help Sadie with hers.
She could remind him of every missed birthday, every volleyball game, every school event where Sadie had looked toward the entrance hoping to see him walk through the door.
But Jodi knew Rory.
She knew how the conversation would unfold.
If she called angry, he would become defensive.
He would say she was always trying to make him look like the bad guy. He would say she didn't understand how difficult things had been at the welding shop. He would remind her that Tasha had her own money and that he couldn't control what his wife chose to spend it on.
Eventually, he would hang up.
Then he might not call Sadie for two weeks.
And Sadie would wonder whether she had caused the argument.
If Jodi called calmly, the conversation would probably go differently.
Rory would agree with her.
He would say he understood.
He would promise to speak to Sadie, perhaps even promise to help with the dress after all.
For a moment, Jodi would feel relieved.
Then nothing would happen.
And Sadie would once again be left waiting.
Jodi had experienced both versions too many times to believe either one would change anything.
She and Rory had married when they were twenty-two.
Their wedding took place in a Lutheran church in Howard, the small South Dakota town where Rory had grown up. His mother, Darla, had done the hair of nearly every woman in the wedding party.
At the time, Rory seemed like the kind of man who could build a life with someone.
He worked as a welder at a trailer manufacturer in Madison. He was funny, practical, and good with his hands. If something broke, he could usually repair it.
When Sadie was born, Rory seemed completely transformed.
He carried her everywhere.
At the county fair, he would place her on his shoulders so she could see the tractor pull. He bought her little toys from the fairground stalls and made her laugh by pretending to be frightened whenever she reached for his beard.
For several years, Jodi believed they were building the kind of family that would last.
Then Rory began staying late at the bar after work.
Sometimes he came home late.
Sometimes he didn't come home at all.
When Sadie was six, Jodi discovered messages from Tasha on his phone.
The marriage ended eight months later.
Rory moved to Mitchell. Two years after the divorce, he married Tasha, who already had a daughter named Madison.
Madison was almost exactly Sadie's age.
She was six months younger.
Rory's new household became his center of gravity.
Sadie still visited every other weekend when schedules allowed. Rory paid child support through the state, and the Department of Social Services deducted $612 each month from his paycheck.
He had never missed a payment.
Jodi acknowledged that.
But the money was only one part of being a father.
There were other things that could not be deposited into a bank account.
He missed Sadie's first piano recital.
He missed most of her volleyball games.
He missed her eighth-grade graduation because Madison had a dance competition in Sioux Falls on the same day.
He usually called on her birthday, although not always.
He sent a card with twenty dollars inside.
He took her every other weekend, unless work or Madison's activities got in the way.
He wasn't completely absent.
That was what made the situation so difficult to explain.
Jodi believed Rory loved Sadie.
She had never doubted that.
But love was supposed to be more than a feeling someone carried privately. It was supposed to become action. It was supposed to mean showing up, remembering, noticing, and making room.
Rory seemed to love Sadie from a distance.
Almost like she was a photograph on a wall that he walked past every day without stopping to look at.
Jodi remembered something her counselor had told her five years earlier.
You can't make him be the father she needs, Jodi. You can only be the mother she needs.
She had repeated those words to herself through years of disappointment.
She had tried not to criticize Rory in front of Sadie. She had tried to make visits work. She had tried to protect her daughter from the anger she sometimes felt.
But she couldn't make him show up.
She couldn't make him spend time with Sadie.
And she couldn't make him pay for a prom dress simply because his daughter wanted one.
The court order required $612 a month.
It did not require him to attend volleyball games.
It did not require him to remember school events.
And it did not require him to make his daughter feel important.
Jodi put the phone down.
She wasn't going to call him.
Instead, she began thinking about someone else.
Someone who had never missed a birthday.
Someone who had never treated Sadie as an appointment that could be postponed.
Someone who had driven through an ice storm just to bring a little girl a birthday cake.