Before a workout, a ripe banana may be convenient.
When baking, an extremely brown banana may be exactly what you need.
If you're experimenting with resistant starch and tolerate less-ripe fruit well, a green banana may have a place in your diet.
The same fruit can serve different purposes depending on the situation.
That's much more useful than labeling one stage "good" and another "bad."
A Simple Banana Ripeness Guide
Here's an easy way to think about the stages:
Green
Texture: Firm
Flavor: Mild, less sweet
Carbohydrates: More starch, including resistant starch
Best for: Savory preparations or people who prefer firmer fruit
Yellow
Texture: Soft but firm
Flavor: Naturally sweet
Carbohydrates: More starch has converted to sugars
Best for: Everyday snacking
Yellow With Brown Spots
Texture: Soft
Flavor: Sweeter
Carbohydrates: More readily available sugars
Best for: Smoothies, oatmeal, yogurt, snacks
Very Brown
Texture: Very soft
Flavor: Very sweet
Carbohydrates: Most of the original starch has been converted
Best for: Baking and cooking
Moldy or Decomposing
Texture: Breaking down abnormally
Flavor/odor: Rotten or unusual
Best for: The trash—not the kitchen